Re: On Beaming
Posted: 29 Jan 2016, 21:11
It is possible to remove the staff lines in F with the Pettersson beams plugin.
The cheating is what fascinates me.Peter West wrote:The aim with beams is to enhance the experience of the eye following the contour of the notes and to avoid ugly white wedges where a beam intersects a stem line or a black wedge where a beam barely touches a line so the line makes it look thicker. 3 or 4 beams are difficult to angle well when they lie in the staff. There is a threshold at which the angle of the note contour is so steep that we no longer need to play with minute adjustments of angles, but can boldly angle them across the staff without causing wedges, as in the Gal Hartman example. He has however cheated a little by removing the staff lines where they might be ugly. this is not possible in Finale or Sibelius, but could be achieved by exporting to illustrator.
I don't think this is correct. Patterson Beams has the ability to create 'French beams', where the stems do not cross the beams (except for at the outer edges), but I don't think erasing staff lines behind beams is an option.OCTO wrote:It is possible to remove the staff lines in F with the Pettersson beams plugin.
Here's the entire sample page:John Ruggero wrote:I think that implementing this is something that a Finale plug-in developer might be interested in.
It is probably rash to say this without seeing this "opaque" beaming in action
Really? I don't see how to do that. There is a "French beams" option, which removes the STEMS between the beams, I don't see where it removes the STAFF lines.OCTO wrote:It is possible to remove the staff lines in F with the Pettersson beams plugin.
I can see your point in the majority of cases, Peter, but I have to say that angling 32nd beams or smaller without the stafflines intersecting in an undesirable way sometimes seems next to impossible. The long beam groups in Homage à r. by Xenakis is certainly a good example of this.Peter West wrote:Really? I don't see how to do that. There is a "French beams" option, which removes the STEMS between the beams, I don't see where it removes the STAFF lines.OCTO wrote:It is possible to remove the staff lines in F with the Pettersson beams plugin.
Sorry guys, my page didn't update so I hadn't noticed people already said this. However, I think it is ugly. The skill of beam angle adjustment is one of the arts of good engraving. I think removing the staff lines looks like an ugly erasure and repair has been made.
MJCube wrote:Something else jumped out at me the moment I looked at Knut’s example: The angle of those beams is so steep that both the beams and the spaces between are noticeably thinner than normal. Like using a “shear” tool in a graphics program. (See Making Notes, Part 10, the subhead “Shearing vs. rotating beams” for a thorough examination.)
Because of this, I didn’t even notice the erasure of staff lines until it was pointed out, and even then I had forgotten that French beams omit the stems (not the staff lines) until it was explained. I have to say I do like the suppressed staff lines. And it would be even more of an advantage with the beam angle less steep, where the “wedge” hazard is greater.