There are so many examples giving different results, that it's hard to decide which is more "logical".
So, what are people's opinions on ties and single-note tremolos?
imagine if you will a long sequence of whole notes, a single note covering multiple bars, played tremolo.
Normally, if it weren't for the tremolo I'd simply use a regular tie for this.
- but with tremolo I've seen the argument that since they are themselves repeated notes, no tie between them is necessary.
- I've heard performers play un-tied tremolo notes with a slight break or accentuation, which is not necessarily the desired sound result.
- some seem to promote the use of a dashed or dotted tie for this type of situation.
- others have suggested a simple regular tie is fine.
I'm not really seeing any proscription or prohibition in Gould, other than her comment that with a dashed/dotted tie accidentals be repeated.