Triplet across beat?

Discuss the rules of notation, standard notation practices, efficient notation practices and graphic design.
User avatar
David Ward
Posts: 526
Joined: 05 Oct 2015, 19:50
Location: Aberdeenshire, Scotland
Contact:

Triplet across beat?

Post by David Ward »

The general view is that A is acceptable but B is not. Do members of this forum believe there any situations where B would be OK? Perhaps in a free cadenza-like passage in which exact counting/ensemble is not the point?

And what about triplets across the middle beats of 4/4? I suspect I may sometimes have written C rather than D depending on context.
Attachments
Screenshot 2020-02-20 at 08.11.20.png
Screenshot 2020-02-20 at 08.11.20.png (272.05 KiB) Viewed 7181 times
Finale 25.5 & F 26.3.1
Mac OS 10.13.6 & 10.14.6
https://composers-uk.com/davidward/news-links/
MalteM
Posts: 67
Joined: 07 Aug 2018, 18:26

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by MalteM »

Ok, I’m not a professional engraver but looking at A before reading your post I simply thought “WTF”. B is much more understandable in this case IMO. Dotted notes under a triplet make it hard for me to see immediately when the a should sound. I tried to make an alternative version of A/B, see attachment. But I’m not sure that that is the best solution either.

Edit: All solutions with lots of ties, dots, and tuplets give me as a performer the feeling of being hard to play. I focus on counting instead on a nice melody. I prefer one written note for one sounding note where you don’t want to “hear the counting”.
Attachments
document.jpg
document.jpg (13.07 KiB) Viewed 7174 times
User avatar
John Ruggero
Posts: 2453
Joined: 05 Oct 2015, 14:25
Location: Raleigh, NC USA

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by John Ruggero »

I think that rhythms B and C (intelligently applied, of course) are fine in solo piano music or orchestral scores, for example, where there might be other voices to clarify them. However, I believe that Arnstein would have decomposed C into D, and B into the suggestion by MaiteM when such rhythms appear in the instrumental parts. I, personally, would not use A under any circumstances.
M1 Mac mini (OS 12.4), Dorico, Finale 25.5, GPO 4, Affinity Publisher 2, SmartScore 64 Pro, JW Plug-ins, TG Tools, Keyboard maestro

http://www.cantilenapress.com
Anders Hedelin
Posts: 274
Joined: 16 Aug 2017, 16:36
Location: Sweden

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by Anders Hedelin »

It may be a matter of preferences, but personally I find the notation in David's A easier to read than in B. In A you have to understand two things only: that it is based on a quarter triplet, and that on each beat of that triplet there's a dotted rhythm. In B you have to subdivide the quarter triplet in your mind in a more complex and irregular way, for example as shown by MalteM.
The notion that B would work better in a free cadenza seems plausible, though.

From C and D, I would prefer D, I think. Depends on the context naturally.
Finale 26, 27 on Windows 10
User avatar
John Ruggero
Posts: 2453
Joined: 05 Oct 2015, 14:25
Location: Raleigh, NC USA

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by John Ruggero »

An example of where I would prefer B:
example.jpeg
example.jpeg (37.95 KiB) Viewed 7107 times
M1 Mac mini (OS 12.4), Dorico, Finale 25.5, GPO 4, Affinity Publisher 2, SmartScore 64 Pro, JW Plug-ins, TG Tools, Keyboard maestro

http://www.cantilenapress.com
Anders Hedelin
Posts: 274
Joined: 16 Aug 2017, 16:36
Location: Sweden

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by Anders Hedelin »

Interesting, and a very nice idea, if I may say so. It looks simple, but I think you would have to practise it once or twice before playing it.
Last edited by Anders Hedelin on 22 Feb 2020, 15:25, edited 1 time in total.
Finale 26, 27 on Windows 10
Anders Hedelin
Posts: 274
Joined: 16 Aug 2017, 16:36
Location: Sweden

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by Anders Hedelin »

And I couldn't rerfain from trying to find a situation where David's A would make sense.
Triplets.JPG
Triplets.JPG (28.88 KiB) Viewed 7093 times
Last edited by Anders Hedelin on 22 Feb 2020, 17:03, edited 1 time in total.
Finale 26, 27 on Windows 10
benwiggy
Posts: 835
Joined: 11 Apr 2016, 19:42

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by benwiggy »

I see nothing wrong with C. If you can span the halfway point for syncopation, why not for triplets. As a singer of little brain, it's much more readable that D. Is there a reason you wouldn't do D with just one bracket?
Anders Hedelin
Posts: 274
Joined: 16 Aug 2017, 16:36
Location: Sweden

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by Anders Hedelin »

Understanding irregular rhythms can be made easy, or natural by establishing a recurring pattern. In measures 3 and 4 below there is such a pattern, in itself not that difficult, but quite common in the Swedish folk dance "Polska". For Swedish folk musicians it would come quite automatically, I would think.
Swedish Polska.JPG
Swedish Polska.JPG (17.24 KiB) Viewed 7082 times
Finale 26, 27 on Windows 10
User avatar
John Ruggero
Posts: 2453
Joined: 05 Oct 2015, 14:25
Location: Raleigh, NC USA

Re: Triplet across beat?

Post by John Ruggero »

Thank you, Anders. And your clever example convinces me about A, so I take back my negative comment about A. Context is everything.

But i would be nervous about writing A, B or C in a single staff orchestral part without some sort of cue. Probably my Arnstein training to avoid anything that can stop a rehearsal. On the other hand, the Swedish folk rhythms you illustrated shouldn't give a professional orchestral player issues.
M1 Mac mini (OS 12.4), Dorico, Finale 25.5, GPO 4, Affinity Publisher 2, SmartScore 64 Pro, JW Plug-ins, TG Tools, Keyboard maestro

http://www.cantilenapress.com
Post Reply