Should I extend the stem?

Discuss the rules of notation, standard notation practices, efficient notation practices and graphic design.
Post Reply
LSL2026
Posts: 152
Joined: 07 Jun 2026, 01:07

Should I extend the stem?

Post by LSL2026 »

It’s always something isn’t it. Never really noticed this before, but 2nd with an 8th note flag, and I have:
Screenshot 2026-06-14 at 8.15.09 PM.png
Screenshot 2026-06-14 at 8.15.09 PM.png (14.73 KiB) Viewed 1728 times
Should I extend the stem to get the flag out of the middle of the note more?

Or is this pretty acceptable as is?
Guitarist, Composer, Music Educator, Engraver.
User avatar
Shinianqi
Posts: 46
Joined: 27 Sep 2023, 08:14
Location: People's Republic of China

Re: Should I extend the stem?

Post by Shinianqi »

In short, this is basically a music font issue. Some fonts can avoid this situation with the default stem length, while others cannot.

Whether to adjust it comes down to personal preference. Visually speaking, neither having the flag cut into the notehead nor excessively extending the stem looks ideal – and personally, I think the latter is worse than the former in most cases.

So I'd say leaving it as is is perfectly acceptable.
Music engraving is the art of balance.

MacOS Sequoia (15.7)
🎼 Finale v26/27 · Dorico 6
🎨 Illustrator · InDesign · Figma · Sketch · Inkscape · Blender
LSL2026
Posts: 152
Joined: 07 Jun 2026, 01:07

Re: Should I extend the stem?

Post by LSL2026 »

Shinianqi wrote: 15 Jun 2026, 01:08 In short, this is basically a music font issue. Some fonts can avoid this situation with the default stem length, while others cannot.

Whether to adjust it comes down to personal preference. Visually speaking, neither having the flag cut into the notehead nor excessively extending the stem looks ideal – and personally, I think the latter is worse than the former in most cases.

So I'd say leaving it as is is perfectly acceptable.
Thanks. There’s only 1 instance in the piece IIRC.

I could extend it just enough so it matches the previous stem or a bit closer so it doesn’t look out of proportion, but too much looks goofy for sure.
Guitarist, Composer, Music Educator, Engraver.
User avatar
Magnus Johansson
Posts: 270
Joined: 07 Oct 2025, 10:51
Location: Sweden
Contact:

Re: Should I extend the stem?

Post by Magnus Johansson »

LSL2026 wrote: 15 Jun 2026, 00:19
Should I extend the stem to get the flag out of the middle of the note more?
Hello! Yes, I think the pennant of an eighth note should always have its tip visible.
Igor Engraver 1.7 via CrossOver on Debian GNU/Linux or Q4OS.
User avatar
Vogel
Posts: 27
Joined: 29 Jan 2026, 16:10
Contact:

Re: Should I extend the stem?

Post by Vogel »

It's common for flags to touch noteheads (see image), so I don't see this as an issue.

I usually only extend a stem when its flag would collide with a rhythm dot.
flag_notehead.png
flag_notehead.png (14.02 KiB) Viewed 1663 times
Augmented Fifth - the intersection between AI & music. I'm on Twitter/X
LSL2026
Posts: 152
Joined: 07 Jun 2026, 01:07

Re: Should I extend the stem?

Post by LSL2026 »

Vogel wrote: 15 Jun 2026, 17:17 It's common for flags to touch noteheads (see image), so I don't see this as an issue.

I usually only extend a stem when its flag would collide with a rhythm dot.

flag_notehead.png
Sure, I just think it looks a little extra odd here becuase the stem is measured from the G, not the A, so the flag is the distance it would have been if this were a downstemmed note, but it’s a space shorter for this 2nd (the A).
Guitarist, Composer, Music Educator, Engraver.
Post Reply